AI isn't killing Excel; it’s shifting the baseline toward workflow design. Senior modelers with deep business judgment are safer than ever. The middle layer doing manual reporting without automation skills or strategic context is getting squeezed.
Every finance thread devolves into the same debate: Will AI kill spreadsheets, or is Excel immortal?
That's the wrong question. The real divide isn't tool preference. It's whether you can design trustworthy, auditable workflows around both.
1. Workflow Engineering > Prompting
Basic prompting, such as summarizing memos and drafting emails, yields near-zero operational leverage. Anyone can do it, and it changes nothing about how the month-end close actually runs.
The real advantage belongs to professionals who can engineer repeatable data pipelines, build validation guardrails to catch bad numbers, and wire automation into core models without sacrificing auditability.
2. The Squeeze Hits Rote Processors, Not Experts
There’s a myth that senior modelers are on the chopping block. The opposite is true:
Domain Experts: A skilled modeler pairing business intuition with AI scripting becomes exponentially faster. Because they know what "right" looks like, they can automate aggressively while instantly spotting AI hallucinations.
The Middle Layer: Analysts spending 40 hours a week on repetitive, manual reporting without developing deep strategic context or automation chops face the real risk. Mechanical work without domain judgment is what automation eats first.
3. Market Expectations vs. Operational Reality
Hiring demands and internal realities are at war. BCG and CFO Dive data show AI adoption in finance has crossed 56%, with nearly 1 in 3 roles explicitly requiring AI skills.
Yet inside many finance orgs, legacy habits dominate. New hires brought in to modernize processes end up acting as human routers for macro-heavy .xlsx files and manual sign-offs. This friction between leadership’s hiring vision and actual operations is a primary driver of burnout.
4. Escaping the "Uncomfortable Middle"
Many practitioners are hedging, clinging to manual spreadsheet habits while running partially automated workflows they don't fully trust or validate. This in-between zone builds neither domain judgment nor durable technical skills.
The Path Forward
Anchor on strategic judgment: Master the business context behind the numbers.
Automate routine assembly: Systematically eliminate manual data wrangling.
Own the thinking, delegate the plumbing: The tech stack will continuously shift, but combining deep judgment with automated workflows remains permanently valuable.
Una AI helps FP&A teams move beyond spreadsheet-heavy workflows with AI-native planning, forecasting, and reporting built for modern finance.
Ready to take control of your budgeting, planning, forecasting and reporting? Schedule a demo and see how Una’s financial planning & analysis software can work for you.
Schedule Demo
